Low-Carb and Keto Myths Debunked: 15 Lies the Internet Keeps Repeating, and the Science-Backed Truth

Low-carb and ketogenic diets get judged online every day. Much of what you read is wrong or outdated. Below are the top myths, what the evidence shows, and where the evidence comes from. I include sources from peer-reviewed journals, leading medical groups, and long-running clinical programs.

Top 15 myths and the facts

1. Myth: Ketosis equals ketoacidosis.
   Fact: Nutritional ketosis shows ketones in a normal range and normal blood pH. Diabetic ketoacidosis shows high glucose, high ketones, and acidosis. These are different states. Nutrition programs aim for about 0.5 to 3.0 mmol/L ketones, not the dangerous levels seen in DKA.

2. Myth: Low-carb harms kidneys.
   Fact: Trials in type 2 diabetes show stable or improved kidney markers over one to five years when carbohydrate intake is restricted with medical supervision. Several analyses report a slower decline in eGFR and lower albuminuria in real-world cohorts using a supervised low-carb approach.

3. Myth: LDL always skyrockets, so risk always goes up.
   Fact: Lipids shift in a mixed way. Triglycerides usually fall and HDL rises. LDL responses vary by person and by fat sources. Particle size often shifts toward larger LDL, while some lean individuals show marked LDL-C rises that need management. Read the lipids as a panel, not a single number. Work with your clinician to adjust saturated and unsaturated fat sources if LDL-C rises.

4. Myth: It is water weight only.
   Fact: At 6 to 12 months, low-carb produces real fat loss and A1c drops. At 12 to 24 months, weight outcomes look similar to low-fat on average, with stronger glycemic improvements and medication reductions in carbohydrate-restricted groups. Long trials in type 2 diabetes show sustained weight loss and better A1c with continuous support.

5. Myth: No medical group supports low-carb.
   Fact: The American Diabetes Association lists carbohydrate reduction as the approach with the most evidence for lowering glucose. Low or very low-carb is a viable option for selected adults with type 2 diabetes. Individualization is the key.

6. Myth: Low-carb starves the brain of glucose.
   Fact: Your liver makes glucose through gluconeogenesis, and ketones provide an efficient fuel for the brain during carbohydrate restriction. Clinical programs show improved glycemic control without hypoglycemia in supervised settings.

7. Myth: Athletes always perform worse.
   Fact: Results depend on sport and intensity. Keto adaptation raises fat oxidation, yet several elite studies show reduced exercise economy and impaired high-intensity performance. For long steady work, performance looks mixed, not universally worse. Match the diet to the event, the person, and the intensity demands.

8. Myth: Low-carb wrecks the gut microbiome.
   Fact: Effects are mixed and depend on food quality. Trials report shifts in microbial composition that track with weight loss and metabolic gains, and some studies report neutral or favorable changes when protein and non-starchy vegetables anchor the plan. Quality and fiber sources matter.

9. Myth: Keto causes nutrient deficiencies by definition.
   Fact: Any restrictive pattern risks gaps if built on narrow food choices. Plans that include meat, eggs, seafood, low-carb vegetables, nuts, seeds, olives, and mineral-rich water meet needs well for most adults. Professional guidelines emphasize individualization rather than fixed macronutrient percentages.

10. Myth: You lose muscle on low-carb.
    Fact: Higher protein within low-carb helps preserve lean mass during weight loss. Meta-analyses show equal or better lean mass retention vs low-fat when protein is adequate and resistance training is present.

11. Myth: Low-carb ruins thyroid function in healthy adults.
    Fact: Human data in healthy adults show no harmful effect on TSH and mixed changes in T3 and T4 during short-term keto periods. Weight loss itself shifts thyroid hormones across diets. Monitor if you have thyroid disease, but blanket claims of harm are not supported by robust adult data.

12. Myth: Fatty liver gets worse on low-carb.
    Fact: Trials in obesity and metabolic dysfunction show reduced liver fat and improved liver markers with low-carb or low-carb high-fat diets during weight loss. Data sets vary, but direction of change is favorable when weight and insulin drop.

13. Myth: Low-carb is not sustainable.
    Fact: Adherence looks similar to other diets in long trials. People stick with what fits their preferences and support system. Some programs report multi-year retention with telemedicine support and steady outcomes.

14. Myth: Keto flu means the diet is harmful.
    Fact: Early symptoms often reflect sodium and fluid shifts during keto-adaptation. Studies and clinical guidance highlight hydration and electrolytes to reduce headaches, cramps, and fatigue during the first two weeks.

15. Myth: Low-carb works only through calories.
    Fact: Calorie deficit drives weight loss in every diet, yet carbohydrate restriction improves glycemia and lowers insulin needs beyond weight loss alone in type 2 diabetes. Medication reductions and A1c improvements outpace many control diets in supervised trials.

Dr. Westman coauthored the “12 points of evidence” review that argued for carbohydrate restriction as a first-line option in diabetes care. The paper cites strong evidence for improved glycemia, fewer medications, and better triglycerides and HDL. This review helped shift professional conversations toward individualized carbohydrate targets.

Bart Kay argues online for low-carb from a physiology angle. Use his videos for debate topics, but ground your claims in peer-reviewed trials and consensus reports when you publish. The sources above give you that footing.

How to use this truth in real life

• Match carbs to your goal. For diabetes or prediabetes, lower carb intake improves A1c and lowers meds in trials. For weight loss, low-carb performs as well as low-fat at one to two years when adherence is equal.
• Prioritize protein and whole-food fats. Favor eggs, meat, fish, cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, olives, avocado, nuts, and olive oil. This supports satiety, lean mass, and lipids. The lipid panel guides your fat mix.
• Eat low-carb vegetables daily. Leafy greens, brassicas, cucumbers, peppers, zucchini, and herbs support potassium, magnesium, and fiber targets within a low-carb plan.
• Hydrate with minerals. Early electrolyte losses are normal. Replace sodium, potassium, and magnesium during the first weeks to reduce symptoms.
• Monitor and individualize. Track A1c, fasting glucose, lipids, blood pressure, weight, and symptoms with your clinician. Adjust carbohydrate level and fat sources to meet your targets.

You deserve clear information. Low-carb and keto are evidence-based tools for the right person, used the right way. They are not magic, and they are not dangerous when you personalize the plan and monitor your markers. Share this with anyone who wants less drama and more science.

Sources

• ADA 2019 Consensus Report on Nutrition Therapy for Diabetes. Carbohydrate reduction holds the strongest evidence for lowering glucose.
• Virta Health multi-year trials on type 2 diabetes with medication reduction, weight loss, and cardiometabolic improvements.
• Feinman RD et al. Dietary carbohydrate restriction as the first approach in diabetes management. Nutrition 2015.
• DIETFITS trial (Gardner CD et al. JAMA 2018). Low-fat vs low-carb, equal weight loss at one year with whole foods and adherence.
• Trials on renal outcomes in low-carb (Brinkworth et al. Am J Clin Nutr 2010; Westman et al. Ann Intern Med 2008).
• Lipid response studies (Volek JS et al. Ann Intern Med 2004; Virta Health data sets).
• Keto adaptation and athletic performance reviews (Burke LM et al. J Physiol 2017; Shaw DM et al. J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2019).
• Gut microbiome studies (Wu GD et al. Science 2011; David LA et al. Nature 2014).
• Thyroid data in keto (Bisschop PH et al. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2001).
• Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease trials (Tay J et al. Diabetes Care 2018).
• Keto flu and electrolytes (Phinney SD, Volek JS. The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Living).

---

Disclaimer: The content shared here is for informational and educational purposes only and should never be taken as medical advice.

In writing this blog post, my goal is to distill research findings into a clear, approachable format that encourages critical thinking and empowers you to make informed decisions about your health.